Journal Matcher. Stage 2: Editor assigned Keep lettering consistently sized throughout your final-sized artwork, usually about 2-3 mm (8-12 pt). If the editor is satisfied with your work, they will choose appropriate peer reviewers to evaluate your work, taking into account several factors including expertise, experience . It must be an omission on part of the # 2 reviewer. Springer will send anonymised copies of these reports to the author(s). The 0.1 and 0.2 wt.% Sc were added into 7055 alloy during the preparation process by conventional casting. The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer-Verlag GmbH, DE part of Springer Nature. The manuscript becomes acceptable for publication if the changes proposed by the reviewers and editors are successfully addressed. According to editor guideline on springer website "Accept with minor revisions is actually a commitment to ultimately publish the paper, provided the authors answer the remaining concerns (which should be relatively minor) in a timely and proper way." The journal requires full consistency with JME style only when an accept with minor revisions decision is reached, but some authors opt to implement these elements after receiving an accept with major revisions decision. ISBN -387-95457- See Also. If the editor feels that your manuscript has the potential to be published, but requires changes, you'll be invited to revise it. 1053 Vigdis, provisional designation 1925 WA, is a bright background asteroid from the central regions of the asteroid belt, approximately 9 kilometers (5.6 miles) in diameter.It was discovered on 16 November 1925, by German astronomer Max Wolf at the Heidelberg-Knigstuhl State Observatory in Heidelberg, Germany. For each paper, we provide the submission-to-decision history. Manuscripts are then either accepted, rejected or authors are required to make major or minor revisions (both reviewer comments and editorial comments may need to be addressed). For papers evaluated as 'Accept after Minor Revision', papers are returned to the corresponding authors for minor revision. After the review. The revised manuscript will be sent back to all (or a selection of) reviewers for a second round of reviews. b) Acceptable with minor revision: Please select this option, if you consider the present manuscript suitable for Polar Biology and if the changes required are only minor. Some journals send reviewers the comments of other reviewers on the same manuscript along with the decision letter; reading . At Springer Publishing Company (SPC) we understand the importance of peer review and we are committed to providing a rigorous, ethical review process on all our journals. Demographics, surgical data and post-operative outcomes were recorded and analyzed. Hi to mention the first sci! Minor revision - if the manuscript needs only light revisions or corrections. After incorporating the comments of reviewers, I resubmitted the paper. NOT. Once your manuscript passes the initial quality check, we assign it to a member of Editorial Board, who is an active researcher in your field. Comment 2: Use a 1" margin on all sides: Done. You should be specific about the revisions you're suggesting. Revision surgery defines secondary operative intervention in cases of total hip arthro plasty for whatever reason this has to be undertaken. You should be specific about the revisions you're suggesting. take offense. Minor revision; Accept; Decisions are communicated to the corresponding author in a formal letter, along with reviewer feedback and any other requirements from the journal office. Minor/Major Revisions Submitted in SCI Journals. Each review will include a recommendation: accept without change/accept with minor revision/accept with major revision/reject. Fourth Edition. Having early and rapid access to research findings is fundamental to the advancement of science and discovery. During peer review, reviewers will be able to access your manuscript securely using our online system, whilst maintaining referee anonymity. If major revision is recommended, the . . Overall, there were 1.3 0.7 reviewers and 1.1 0.6 revisions per protocol. Revisions. If major revision is recommended, the . Stage 2: Editor assigned. For LaTeX submissions, authors should use the VLDB LaTeX Template when preparing a submission. all. Minor revision: Submissions that receive this decision will require some revisions before being accepted for publication. Papers having two reviewers' recommendations to accept and minor revision have much greater chance of acceptance (more than 98%) than papers receiving two reviewers' recommendations that include a major revision and a reject or two rejections (which results in an acceptance rate of less than 5%): (Figure 1). 1) OVERALL RECOMMENDATION: a) Acceptable without revision: This option meaning 'publish as is' does usually apply after revision only. Attributing to the Sc additions, the grain sizes of as-cast ingots were remarkably refined and the irregular grain morphology changed to . . Then, I have made all the necessary . For papers evaluated as 'Accept as is', these papers are published as they are received. To respond to your queries until then, it's a bit unusual that the revised manuscript (for a minor revision decision) has gone to Under Review, which mostly means that the peer reviewer/s need/s to look at your changes. Minor revision of mvrnorm (from MASS) . As appeals are matters of journal policy they are given lower priority than new submissions and may take at least several weeks . For editors and reviewers to accurately assess the work presented in your manuscript you need to ensure the English language is of sufficient quality to be understood. In the case that a paper is accepted with minor revisions, authors have up to two weeks to return the revised manuscript. Then, I have made all the necessary. Here are responses to the reviewer comments: Comment 1: Language editing for the manuscript has been done. Strictly speaking, for truly minor revisions, it's possible that the editor accepts your paper and leaves you to make the remaining changes during proofs. Cite 1 Recommendation 14th Oct, 2021 Peterson K. Peer review characteristics and processing time. part of Springer Nature. Face Frontalization Based on Robustly Fitting a . For some journals, including JGME, major versus minor is not determined by the number of comments, but by the journal's commitment to publish. springer, The quantity of numbered minor planets has now well exceeded a quarter million. Read more. Divide the list into two sections: major issues and minor issues. Should you wish to do so, then please review our style checklist. Thus it includes a broad spectrum of operative procedures from minor ones to a full-scale exchange. In this situation, if all requested changes are made, a minor . This may be the case if one/some of the changes they asked for are very technical. Major revision . This letter usually contains information on how to return your revised manuscript including instructions on how to highlight the changes made and when you need to return the revised version. Indexed in SCI, Thomson Reuters. In this case, the paper should probably be rejected, because two major revisions are not allowed. Minor revisions not involving the tibial or femoral components were also excluded. If minor revision is recommended, the author(s) will amend the manuscript at their own discretion. Publish with us Authors & Editors Journal authors Publishing ethics Open Access & Springer. . Once a revised manuscript is re-submitted, it is assessed along with the responses to reviewer comments and if it has been adequately revised it will be accepted for . Among other elements, note that JME style mandates that . Typically, a reviewer's decision falls in four categories: acceptance without revision, acceptance after minor revision, acceptance after major revision, and rejection. . For revised submissions we strongly recommend to upload the editable source files (either Word or LaTeX) together with a PDF of the . At the submission stage, authors may indicate a limited . Springer's speed, and eternal god! . No, minor revision doesn't mean accepted with minor revisions. Major revision . The reviewers' and editors' comments provide guideposts as to why a paper receives a "major" versus "minor" revision decision. A retrospective observational cohort study including all primary admitted trauma patients was . The status of my paper changed to"Editor assignment pending". with comments and recommended revisions. (Impact Factor: 3.818). Manu- The microstructure and tensile properties of hot-extruded Al-8Zn-2Mg-2Cu-.15Zr alloy (7055 alloy) with the minor addition of Sc were investigated. You'll have 45 days . comments carefully (Daniel . Indexed in SCI, Thomson Reuters. Latest update: 01/22/2021 PERCEPTION papers available on arXiv Journal papers submitted in 2020 Z. Kang, M. Sadeghi and R. Horaud (October 2020). Manuscripts are then either accepted, rejected or authors are required to make major or minor revisions (both reviewer comments and editorial comments may need to be addressed). Software versioning is the process of assigning either unique version names or unique version numbers to unique states of computer software. . After several weeks I received an email saying that"Based on the advice received, the Editor feels that your manuscript could be accepted for publication should you be prepared to incorporate minor revisions". The meaning of the asteroids's name is unknown. Repaired yesterday, hired today! Minor revision - if the manuscript needs only light revisions or corrections. "Minor" does not primarily reflect . Some journals will inform reviewers if the manuscript was accepted or rejected, while others do not. If the corrective action delay, you may wish to consult the chairman to the board of reviewers. 3. The overall implant survival, considering both infection recurrences, major and minor revisions, was 83.35% (CI95% 50.7-93.94) at 2 and 5 years (Fig. Editorial Formatting comments: All the suggestions regarding editorial formatting have been incorporated. 3. Toolbox . Generally, when the reviewers make major revisions, it is probably to have minor changes if you answer 80% of the provided comments. For more information about the Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial . At Springer Publishing Company (SPC) we understand the importance of peer review and we are committed to providing a rigorous, ethical review process on all our journals. Springer Nature is committed to accelerating the adoption of open access (OA) publishing and open research techniques. The very rapid development of this field brings with it new demands and necessitates the continuous Appeals of a rejection decision are only successful in a handful of cases and usually only when you can provide strong evidence or new data that can respond to and alleviate the concerns of the editor and reviewers. Discover content SpringerLink Books A-Z Journals A-Z . On this page we archive a list of journal submissions, some of which may or may not be accepted. For first (initial) submissions, we require a single file containing your manuscript as a minimum (LaTeX or PDF). For papers accepted after minor revision, the revised papers are often published without another full process of peer review. TIP: journals have different revision deadlines which vary from as little as a few weeks to three months depending on the revisions that need to be made. Sometimes the ideas are good, the results are enough, but the paper is in such a shambles that a major revision will likely only get the paper to the point where it needs another major revision. The finding was based on the broader interpretation of the TRIPs obligations that limitations and exceptions under the minor exceptions doctrine is (i) primarily concerned with de minimis use, (ii) its application is not limited to the examples contained in the reports of the Berne Convention revision conferences held in Brussels and Stockholm . A threshold Injury Severity Score (ISS) 16 is common in classifying major trauma (MT), although the Abbreviated Injury Scale (AIS) has been extensively revised over time. The emphasis on short turnaround implies that "minor revisions" must be resubmitted within a short period of time and that "major revisions" are treated as rejections. The author assigns the exclusive right to any commercial use of the article to Springer. If you need help with writing in English you should consider: Asking a colleague who is a native English speaker to review your manuscript for clarity. 2021.02.08 submited 2021.05.27 minor revision 2021.06.22 submit revision 2021.06.22 accept - Journal of Supercomputing Forum Forum. Cite. Consider peer review feedback as advice to help you improve your article, do . The revision will be verified by the corresponding associate chair and if approved, the submission will be . Minor revisions required The authors are required to make moderate changes to their manuscript. Each review will include a recommendation: accept without change/accept with minor revision/accept with major revision/reject. Nearly every manuscript requires revisions, often two or three revisions. We oversee this process to ensure that your manuscript contains everything our editors and peer reviewers need to perform a fair and thorough assessment of your work. The new sixth edition of the Dictionary of Minor Planet Names, which is the IAU's official reference work for the field, now covers more than 17,000 named minor planets. categories: accept, minor revisions, major revision and reject. Since the editor didn't do this, it's still possible your paper will be declined. If you receive reviewer comments for re-submission, act. I submitted a manuscript to Springer Journal.